Smith & Wesson: The Truth At Last
In 1855, Rollin White received a patent for a revolver. It was similar to the Colt revolver, but instead of the cylinder chambers being loaded from the front in White’s gun—he cut off the back of the Colt cylinder—they were loaded from behind. In 1856, White licensed that feature to Horace Smith and Daniel Wesson, retaining a royalty. Under the license, Smith & Wesson established a monopoly on the breech-loading revolver, made a fortune, and built an empire.
This story of Smith & Wesson's success with what became known as "the patent for the bored-through cylinder" is oft-told. Alas, at great cost to the nation, it was borne of an illicit scheme; it was all a fraud.
Don’t take my word for it. Gathering the facts and borrowing from arguments made by those whom he had sued for infringement, in his 1874 document Wesson (now the sole owner of Smith & Wesson) declares that White’s invention is a dangerous rattletrap and that his patent should never have been issued.
At the cost of revealing his role in the deception, Wesson sent the document to every member of Congress. He was prepared to do anything to keep Congress from granting White his petition to have his long-expired patents resurrected and extended.
Why? If the petition were granted wouldn’t Smith & Wesson’s license and monopoly be restored? No. As Wesson reveals in the remonstrance, the partners lost their monopoly in 1864 when White managed to get a second patent for a bored-through cylinder. With that, every gun the company made or would make under the license infringed White’s second patent. It plunged Smith & Wesson into a living nightmare. The time had come. It was win or go home.
Why has it taken almost 150 years for this explosive document to be made public? It is referenced in letters found in the Colt archives, but the remonstrance itself is hard to find. As far as I can determine, only two of the few hundred copies printed for Congress survive. The Library of Congress supposedly has one. I found a copy at the Howard Gottlieb Archival Research Center, Mugar Library, Boston University.
In Colt-Smith & Wesson: A Clash of Arms, I included a copy of the remonstrance to complete and inform the narrative of which the sad, sordid bored-through cylinder affair is significant part. In his review, the now-retired Director of the NRA Museums Jim Supica said: “A Trifecta! New Research-Fascinating Subject-Wonderfully Written.”
Available on the homepage and other online booksellers.
Robert Swartz